Your Daily Dose of Park51 Updates and Commentary
Thursday, August 19, 2010 at 7:08PM In a way, I should thank the planners of the so-called Ground Zero Mosque -- otherwise known as Park51 -- for inspiring and rekindling my writing/blogging bug like nothing has since the 2004 Election. I guess everyone needs his or her own muse, no matter how revolting and life-threatening it may be. Conquering Islamo-terrorists, John Frenchy Kerry, it's all the same!
Look for the Union Label
Via @midlifechick on Twitter comes word that many New York City-based unions and vendors may tell the builders of Park 51 to take a flying leap when RFP time rolls around.
I'm no unionist, for sure, but one cannot imagine without being horrified how many hard-working union members -- construction, police, EMT, nurses, food service, clerical, and more -- were murdered during the attack. It's perfectly understandable -- and 100% well within their consitutional rights -- to refuse to work on this project. And if there are no available workers to build the facility (NY is not a right-to-work state), then it's questionable if Park51 will get built at all. A perfect potential solution, completely legal and free of government intervention.
And how ironic it is, indeed, that the heroic leader of the new Blue Collar Corner's name is...Andrew Sullivan.
Just hope for their sakes that Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi doesn't "investigate their financing" as a result.
Rudy Returns!
No less than 24 hours after my lament that the man was gone for good, Rudy Giuliani returned to the political airwaves today, and hit all of the key take-aways with his usual dose of rational delivery.
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Regardless of how he felt on the matter -- and make no mistake, he hit all of the points succinctly and accurately, from legality to sensitivity to a bigger picture -- for a figure so forever entangled with the tragedy of 9/11 to remain silent felt like a gaping void in the debate. Glad to see him again, especially in a fashion which allowed him to rhetorically eviscerate the vapid Ken doll Matt Lauer.
Even Some Muslims Think This Is a Colossal Disaster
Finally, a handful of voices of reason emerge even on the other side of the debate.
American Muslims who support the proposed mosque and Islamic center near ground zero are facing skeptics within their own faith — those who argue that the project is insensitive to Sept. 11 victims and needlessly provocative at a time when Muslims are pressing for wider acceptance in the U.S.
"For most Americans, 9/11 remains as an open wound, and anything associated with Islam, even for Americans who want to understand Islam — to have an Islamic center with so much publicity is like rubbing salt in open wounds," said Akbar Ahmed, professor of Islamic studies at American University, a former Pakistani ambassador to Britain and author of "Journey Into America, The Challenge of Islam." He said the space should include a synagogue and a church so it will truly be interfaith.
Abdul Cader Asmal, past president of the Islamic Council of New England, an umbrella group for more than 15 Islamic centers, said some opponents of the $100 million, 13-story project are indeed anti-Muslim. But he said many Americans have genuine, understandable questions about Islam and extremism.
In light of those fears, and the opposition of many relatives of 9/11 victims, Asmal said organizers should dramatically scale back the project to just a simple mosque, despite their legal right to construct what they want.
"Winning in the court of law is not going to help improve the image of Muslims nationwide," said Asmal, a Massachusetts physician. "You have to win the hearts and minds of the ordinary American people,"
Of course, winning hearts and minds -- at least, by means other than force -- has never exactly been a strong point in a religion based mostly on conquest. Still, it is very reassuring to see that cooler heads do exist and are willing to take a path less provocative and belligerent. Even if some think the whole thing is, of course, part of a vast Zionist Conspiracy. Maybe there's hope for a Great Islamic Reformation after all. Maybe.
H/t to @dorkelina on Twitter for the article above.
Links:
- "Giuliani: If Dialogue and Sensitivity are the Goals, Don't Build the Mosque on Ground Zero" (Hot Air)
- "What Mosque Supporters Won't Say" (Piece of Work in Progress)
- "Some Muslims Question Mosque Near Ground Zero" (The Leaf Chronicle)
- "Top Muslims Condemn Ground Zero Mosque as 'Zionist Conspiracy'" (Pajamas Media)
- "Pelosi Wants Mosque Dissenters Investigated" (Big Government)
- "Workers Pledging Not to Work on Ground Zero Mosque" (Can I Just Finish My Waffle?)

